I joined at 18 with just A-Levels (with a Sixth Form Scholarship) but I have a mixed opinion now of being Commissioned so young.
For:
- If you are only thinking of Uni to get a qualification rather than wanting to go, don't. Join up and get on with it. Everyone has a degree these days and they are therefore devalued (unless a particular degree from a good Uni). Having a degree in some random subject shows you have the ability to study to that level and dedicate yourself to 3 years of learning. Well I think my time was better spent serving in the RAF than eating Tescos Value Beans and skiving off lectures, and now I have 3 years more experience in the Branch than those of my school year that went to Uni.
- The experience you get is invaluable and will shape the rest of your life, especially learning so much so young.
Against:
Joining with just A-Levels is fine, in fact irrelevant except you will have to serve 6 months as Acting Pilot Officer, 2 Years as Pilot Officer and 4 Years as Flying Officer. - Lower pay but 'Bomb-proof'. What is a significant issue is joining at age 18/19 as an Officer. I did it, its all I wanted to do back then, I would not have changed it for the world and it was bloody hard! However, now I look back at the situation I have a different opinion on the matter.
I personally feel that if I was deemed suitable for Commissioning at such a young age, that’s all very well, but there are problems with being a Commissioned teenager! IOT does prepare you for being an adult early. Its very good at developing leadership and Officer skills, however, as you don't actually meet or interact with real Airmen (Apart from the RAF Regt NCOs and PTIs)until after you graduate, you are not fully prepared in terms of the people skills to interact. If you approach Airmen or NCOs with the attitude that you are in any way superior you will last about 5 mins and at age 19 you have no experience. Luckily I coped well, but this was very hard and not from any training that I received; I had to quickly realise that I was effectively an Officer apprentice at least until I made Fg Off. The Plt Off rank badge does help with this but its not ideal. I can look back and cringe at what I must have looked to the guys. When 20 somethings, straight from Uni come into the Branch they look very young to me now, I would have looked like an Air Cadet with an Officers hat. Not that I was not professionally competent, but appearances do matter until you can prove yourself.
I feel that perhaps the way ahead would be for Officers not to be Commissioned until they are at least 21, they could join earlier with a ‘Commission Recommendation’ but perhaps should serve as an Airmen first. Commissioned reckonable service is not recognized before 21 anyway (Any time before is done 'for the Queen' and does not count towards your pension).
I would never have agreed with this opinion back then, but in the cold light of today I seriously think Commissioning so young is not quite right as you don’t have the life experience to back up your actions and opinions. It’s very hard for the young Officer (But you learn quickly!) and its equally controversial for the Airmen who have in front of them a Teenager who they call Sir.
What I will say is those airmen that saw my difficult position an respected that it was a means to an end and that I was an Officer under training looked after me very well, aided my training and development and I will always remember who they were. There were, however, a few, who resented my position, did not see me beyond my 'badge' as anything more than an upstart because I was young. This will happen, although not the norm, and you need to be able to deal with it, remembering that your reputation in the long term can be marked by your decisions and attitude when you were least experienced.
I hope this helps you make your decision as I feel I am ‘qualified’ to give comment.
All the best.